Tuesday, 20 May 2025

ANDOR Season 3... is HBO's CHERNOBYL

 


 

 

 


 If you, like me, a still thinking about ANDOR, a week after the final season finished, I have a suggestion for something to move onto. And it's not more bounty hunters on Tatooine.

HBO's CHERNOBYL mini series excellent as it was, probably wasn't ideal viewing during grim lockdowns in 2019. Right now it is a very effective follow up to a Star Wars show, because - amazingly - it shares a lot of themes, presentation, cast and crew.

 

ANDOR AND CHERNOBYL SHARE THE SAME NIGHTMARE BLUEPRINT


The Crew

 Tony Gilroy (Andor) and Craig Mazin (Chernobyl) have been swimming in the same creative waters for years—gritty, dialogue-driven stories where systems, not supervillains, are the true enemy.

While not the same director, Chernobyl (Johan Renck) and Andor (Toby Haynes, Benjamin Caron, and others) have a shared directorial tone:
 

  • Cold lighting
  • Unsentimental framing
  • Long silences where the truth creeps in


They both feel closer to '70s prestige cinema than modern sci-fi or prestige TV.

The cinematography? The same cold light. The same glacial camera movement, like we’re being slowly drawn into a bureaucratic sarcophagus.

Even the sound design whispers guilt. That dreadful hum of something broken, grinding on, unseen.

 

The Cast - expect to see a few familiar faces 

The fact that these actors work across both shows tells you something: casting directors know they carry the weight of real-world institutional horror on their faces.

Stellan Skarsgård
 In Chernobyl, he is Boris Shcherbina – the gruff Soviet apparatchik who slowly realises the truth and helps expose the cover-up.

In Andor, Luthen Rael – the grim-faced rebel mastermind running a secret war from the shadows.

In both cases he portrays a ruthless pragmatist who sacrifices idealism to save the system from itself. Both are brilliant performances. Both exude cold fury and reluctant duty.

Robert Emms

In Chernobyl, he portrays Leonid Toptunov – one of the junior engineers at Reactor 4 on the night of the disaster.

In Andor, Lonni Jung – the Imperial Security Bureau (ISB) officer secretly working for the Rebellion.

Alex Ferns

In Chernobyl, , he portrays Andrei Glukhov, the leader of the Tula coal miners brought in to dig under the reactor to prevent a second explosion.

In  Andor, Sergeant Linus Mosk, the corporate security officer who teams up with Syril Karn to pursue Cassian in Season 1.



DOOMED "ENERGY PROJECTS" AND MURDERED PLANETS

Chernobyl is a story about a meltdown—both nuclear and moral. So is Andor.

In *Chernobyl*, we have the RBMK reactor: an unstable Soviet invention that explodes when you follow orders.In Andor, we have Project Stardust—better known as the Death Star—an unstable Imperial invention that explodes when you ask too many questions.

Both are dressed up as technological achievements. "Energy projects". Both are designed to project state power.
Both end up committing genocide.
 

In Chernobyl: the people of Ukraine.

In Andor: the people of Aldhani, Ghorman, and eventually, entire star systems.



BUREAUCRACY AS HORROR

Remember Chernobyl’s Lyudmilla Ignatenko? Her husband dying by inches while bureaucrats lie to her through plastic smiles?
Now think of Bix Caleen, strapped to an Imperial torture rig, being asked politely to “cooperate.”
Same nightmare. Different backdrop.
Andor and Chernobyl both show us what happens when the truth becomes inconvenient.


  • When careerists are rewarded for saying “nothing’s wrong.”
  • When someone says “cut corners” and someone else dies horribly.
  • When ideology matters more than physics.


And in both cases, the lies are protected by a paper wall of committees, rank, memos, and fear.


QUIET HEROES AND GRIM HOPE

In Chernobyl, we get Legasov, Shcherbina, Khomyuk. All flawed. All brave. All doomed to be erased, eventually.
In Andor, we get Kino Loy, Dedra Meero (kind of), Luthen Rael, Cassian himself.

Andor may have X-wings and fascist space architects. Chernobyl has graphite and lead aprons.
But both are slow-burn, dialogue-heavy, morally complex stories about what happens when power forgets it's mortal.

Final note

Chernobyl has some resemblances to Andor but for heaven's sake don't mistake it for a follow up to Skeleton Crew. It's grown up stuff. Chernobyl should be shown as a mandatory requirement in government management courses, arguably any management course. The courtroom explanation for what went wrong in the last episode is as gripping as the rest of it (and that's saying something).

Friday, 2 May 2025

One more classic horror movie actor in Star Wars? (Andor Season 2)

.

The emotional whiplash of following Star Wars can be exhausting. As I mentioned in a previous post the awful sequels had driven me away to resentful exile before Clone Wars/Rebels/Rogue One and Andor S1 pulled me back so hard I found myself at Star Wars Celebration in London. Then Book of Boba Fett and the especially dissapointing Kenobi series put me right back into the hater category again...

After 1 episode of Andor S2 I was right back into the Star Wars Universe. Incredible. I'm almost ashamed of myself for being so fickle. There can't be another franchise or property in which has such a chasm between the highs and lows of quality.

Anyway, enough of the moaning, here is some positive observation of  Andor Season 2.

One of the reasons I love Star Wars is we got Peter Cushing's incredible Tarkin in the original, and Christopher Lee's Dooku later as a highlight of the Prequels (and probably the most interesting new character before Rogue One and Andor).

 

Well, in this very familiar discussion about English accents and villians Ben Mendelsohn mentions Vincent Price https://youtu.be/dzGVE1MBT0Y?si=Nxgo3xzuLqInp112

This is nice in the tradtion of old horror movie actors and Star Wars but wierd as Ben is talking about astrocratic American Vincent Price as English. Price is on his mind obviously. Has Ben been basing his portrayal of Krennic on Price?

If so the obvious basis for Krennic would be Vincent Price in very English Witchfinder General but that is a famously locked down performance. It was forced out of Price and he bitterly resented the director until much later in his career.

Krennic is a bit of diva... maybe he is based on Vincent Price from The Masque of the Red Death? 

 

 

Following this example are we going to get some actor doing an Imperial Moff in the manner of Boris Karloff?